Anthony Richardson’s Indianapolis Colts career appeared to be heading towards an uncomfortable ending. Once viewed as the franchise’s quarterback of the future, the former fourth overall pick had slipped down the depth chart, lost his starting position, and reportedly sought a way out of Indianapolis. Now, he has another opportunity.
Following the Colts’ decision to release Daniel Jones, as reported earlier, head coach Shane Steichen has confirmed that Richardson will return as the team’s starting quarterback when Indianapolis faces the New York Giants on November 29.
It will be Richardson’s first start since Week 16 of the 2024 NFL season, giving the 24-year-old a significant opportunity to show that he can still become the quarterback Indianapolis envisioned when it selected him in the 2023 NFL Draft.

From franchise hope to backup quarterback
When the Colts selected Richardson with the fourth overall pick in 2023, they were investing in one of the most physically gifted quarterback prospects in his draft class.
His rookie season provided glimpses of that potential. Richardson threw for 577 yards and three touchdowns in four appearances, while adding 136 rushing yards and four rushing touchdowns.
However, injuries quickly became a recurring problem.
He had a concussion and a shoulder injury limiting him to four games in his rookie campaign. He returned in 2024 but struggled to establish consistency as a passer, completing just 47.7 per cent of his attempts while throwing eight touchdowns and 12 interceptions.
There were also questions about his development and decision-making, particularly after he briefly removed himself from a game against Houston in October 2024 because of fatigue.
Although he eventually regained his starting position, the Colts’ confidence in him appeared to weaken.
Daniel Jones moved ahead, and Richardson fell behind
Richardson’s situation became more complicated when Indianapolis brought in Daniel Jones.
Jones won the starting quarterback competition ahead of the 2025 season, leaving Richardson to watch from the sidelines as the Colts pursued a different direction.
His opportunities became increasingly limited. He appeared in just two games in 2025 without making a start, and his playing time remained restricted during the 2026 campaign.
The Colts also declined to exercise his fifth-year contract option in May 2026, meaning the organization did not commit to keeping him under contract through the 2027 season.
Reports subsequently indicated that Richardson had requested a trade on two occasions, further raising questions about his long-term future in Indianapolis.
For a player selected to become the face of a franchise, the situation represented a significant fall.
Daniel Jones’ departure opens the door again
Indianapolis entered its November 19 meeting with the Houston Texans needing a response after a difficult stretch of the season. Instead, the team suffered a 26-3 defeat, falling to 3-8.
Jones struggled throughout the contest, completing 12 of 27 passes for 144 yards and an interception before being pulled from the game.
The following day, the Colts announced his release and confirmed Richardson would take over as their starting quarterback.
Steichen believes the additional preparation time could benefit the young quarterback, particularly given how much he has matured since entering the league.
Richardson has completed 50.6 per cent of his career passes for 2,408 yards, 11 touchdowns and 13 interceptions across 19 appearances. He has also recorded 640 rushing yards and 10 rushing touchdowns.
Those numbers highlight both sides of his game: the considerable threat he presents as a runner and the inconsistency that has prevented him from establishing himself as a dependable passer.
What must Richardson prove?
Richardson’s physical ability has never been the biggest question.
His arm strength and running ability make him a difficult quarterback to defend when he is operating confidently. The challenge is turning those physical gifts into consistent production.
His accuracy must improve. A career completion percentage of 50.6 per cent is a major concern for a starting quarterback, particularly in an NFL where offences increasingly depend on efficiency and decision-making.
He must also demonstrate better pocket awareness, make quicker reads and protect the football. 13 career interceptions against 11 passing touchdowns underline the importance of becoming more disciplined with his decisions.
Most importantly, Richardson needs to stay healthy.
Availability has repeatedly interrupted his development, preventing him from building the consistency and experience that young quarterbacks need.
Is this his last chance in Indianapolis?
Richardson now has six regular-season games remaining to make a convincing case for his future.
His first assignment against the Giants will carry an interesting subplot, considering that New York was the franchise that moved on from Daniel Jones before he joined Indianapolis.
He has the athleticism, the draft pedigree and now the opportunity.
What remains to be seen is whether he can finally put everything together.


